Posts Tagged ‘audio’

sound sound

Monday, December 8th, 2014


Recently I been doing some video editing.. less editing than tweaking my system tho.
If you want your jack output to speak with Kdenlive, a most excellent video editing suite,
and output audio in a nice way without choppyness and popping, which I promise you is not nice,
you’ll want to pipe it through pulseaudio because the alsa to jack stuff doesn’t do well with phonom, at least not on this convoluted setup.

Remember, to get that setup to work, ALSA pipes to jack with the pcm.jack { type jack .. thing, and remove the alsa to pulseaudio stupidity at /usr/share/alsa/alsa.conf.d/50-pulseaudio.conf

So, once that’s in place, it won’t play even though Pulse found your Jack because your clients are defaulting out on some ALSA device… this is when you change /etc/pulse/client.conf and set default-sink = jack_out.

software defined radios with alsa, jack and pulseaudio and a professional sound card

Monday, September 9th, 2013



All the people out there are neatly divided in two piles:
the “it works for me and does what I need”-camp, and
the “always always always gets in the way so killitwithfire”-camp,
and this fragmentation may be the best argument that pulseaudio should be up for a whammy.

For all of you tl;dr’s (too lazy, doyou read?) here’s a short summary:

  • alsa: just works. confusion in the .asoundrc
  • pulseaudio: controls per process, less buffer fuckups, “just works”
  • jack: controls per process, realtime, firewire/usb, pro audio apps
  • firewire: fantastic, massive pain but getting there
  • software defined radios: so worth it!

But read on to learn the recipie to the secret magic sauce.

The reason I am writing this is not because pulseaudio is evil and sucks. However, it was the last straw in a long and windy road that broke the camels back. Pulseaudio assumes you are running systemd, and talks to console-kit-daemon which is surely one of Satan’s most trusted advisers and a harbinger of the Apocalypse.


We know all this, and yet why do I bother?
I didn’t come here to rant about Pulseaudio though:
I’ve gathered you here today to tell a story about Software Defined Radios.

Introducing a large and characteristic cast of characters, and howto make them work together in the best possible way.

My way.

The Cook

Well: a friend of mine got a hold of a few Terratec DVB-dongles with the awesome rtl-chipset and Elonics tuner, which means I can play with radio!

terratec dongle

Except the first time I tried I got stuck in gnuradio dependency hell and never got anything working… which was very nearly a year ago.

Things weren’t easy back then, gqrx, the pretty waterfall app wasn’t mature enough and you were stuck using something far more fugly (.net code running under mono, shudder the thought).

You still have to build gnuradio from source (because the packaged versions aren’t new and shiny enough), but the piper’s playing to a different tune now, with the advent of build-gnuradio it’s possible to sit back and relax while gnuradio and all its dependencies builds before your very eyes.

Yes indeed this takes longer than getting the cows back from pasture but it’s worth it, because with a full gnuradio build you can now have a hope of getting gqrx the shiny waterfall to compile!

gnuradio companion

The Thief

Except you didn’t realize that without the -m option ti build-gnuradio it builds gnuradio 4.6 which is not 4.7 which gqrx needs! Joke’s on you haha ha ha.

Then you build gqrx and realize you can’t get it to talk to your Terratec, because why? Because it’s a DVB dongle and the kernel has helpfully inserted the DVB module to enable it! So run along now and add

# rtlsdr
blacklist dvb_usb_rtl28xxu

to your /etc/modprobe.d/blacklist.conf – now you are ready to fire up gqrx and gnuradio-companion.

His Wife

That’s when you might discover that if you are lucky there is no sound in gqrx. It’s working and showing you a waterfall but you can’t hear the demodulated waves!

GQRX gnuradio waterfall

Why oh why, well let me tell you why: It absolutely needs, requires Pulseaudio to produce sound!

OK, fair enough, some of you out there are in the “works-for-me”-camp and ipso facto you’re done here, gqrx works and IT ALL JUST WORKS but the world is not so easy for the rest of us.

The rest of us bite the bullet and install pulseaudio to get this thing working. Which is as far as you need to go if you’re semi-sane and normal or even when you are running this thing on a Raspberry PI or you’re building a beagleboard spectrum analyzer.

Actually you don’t even need Pulseaudio for that last project..

Her Lover


What I have neglected to tell you however is that I have an Echo Audiofire. I was impressed with these little firewire-driven sound cards back when my bro had the small and portable Audiofire2.

Sound quality and flexibility wise they are unbeatable, certainly if you want professional quality sound input and output.

Firewire sound also has the major advantage over USB sound in that firewire packets aren’t quantized in time, which means a lot if you’re doing midi or other realtime music stuff. Latency is a killer.

You might also be aware that the higher the sample rate of your sound card, the higher the bandwidth of your homebrew SDR radio..

Anyways, firewire soundcards “just work” with asio drivers in Windoze but are a small pain of their own to set up in Linux. ALSA never heard of them. Pulseaudio doesn’t speak firewire. For anything resembling realtime professional audio under Linux you’ll have to go FFADO and JACK.

JACK audio kit

Also, never think that just any firewire card will work in Linux: a lot of vendors continue to ignore the platform (understandibly, because of the atrocious state of professional audio under linux) and there are some wonderous cards out there that have just pitiful support here.

The jackd brothers

You’re walking down a long path, you’re going to Mecca. You come upon a fork in the road where two brothers live. They are twins, and you know that one of them always speaks the truth, and the other always lies. You need to ask them the way to Mecca, but how?

As there are two problems with anything in this world, there are two problems with Jack. Firstly, jack forked into jack1 and jack2, and both versions are strangely alive to this day, and there is netjack1 and netjack2 and well, what the fuck.


To complicate matters there are two competing linux driver subsystems for firewire and both of them live to this day, with one supporting some firewire devices and one supporting other firewire devices, and one being supported in jack1 and the other in jack2. Furthermore you need a recent FFADO to get it all working.

Thankfully in recent debians and ubuntus the right kind of jackd talks to the right kind of firewire device in the kernel and matches the right ffado to get things to work, but you still need to know your way around.


The Answer, not The Question

Know what question to ask to get the right answer, which is that at least for the Echo Audiofire, jackd2 works nicely with ffado and recent-ish kernels as long as
you run jackd as your X user
with jackd -v -dfirewire and then fire off qjackctl and ffado-mixer and then all your sweet sweet jack apps. For now, lets assume you are jackd2′ing things, but let us just say that at this point it no longer matters.

What you don’t know is that to get the Echo to work, you will likely have to upgrade your Echo firmware, either by hooking it up to a windoze with the right drivers and letting them reflash the rom, or play with the scary commands ffado-diag and ffado-fireworks-downloader, insert magic (literally!), etc.

Having done all this voodoo I still had problems that required rebooting the sound card or booting into windoze to reset it to a known state that jackd could talk to, but with newer kernels/libffado/jackd versions the problem evaporated somewhere along the line.

Jack meters

Realtime patchset to the Linux kernel? Lets not get into it… I am not a professional musician nor am I a sound engineer, and they would probably use windows or mac.

The Waitress


Synthesizer clutter

At that point you might be wondering where I’m going with things. Lets recap:
I’ve got a gqrx waterfall on Terratec DVB RTL-SDR that only supports Pulseaudio, and I’ve got an Echo Audiofire soundcard on firewire that only listens to jack. I can hook pulseaudio to Alsa.

Indeed, installing pulseaudio I discovered it will do this automatically, /usr/share/alsa/alsa.conf.d/pulse.conf suddenly appears and fucks your setup by putting everything in ALSA through Pulseaudio.

There is also some shit in /etc/pulseaudio/ that is supposed to detect jackdbus and make pulseaudio use jack, but that stuff just never worked.

Of course, I have an .asoundrc file that takes everything from ALSA and puts it up JACK, so how do you think that’s gonna work?

Well, it doesn’t work.
So, it’s time to bring out the guns again.

The Heist

# convert alsa API over jack API
# use it with
# % aplay foo.wav

# use this as default
pcm.!default {
    type plug
    slave { 
       pcm "jack" 
       #rate 96000

ctl.mixer0 {
    type hw
    card 1

# pcm type jack
pcm.jack {
    type jack
    playback_ports {
        0 system:playback_1
        1 system:playback_2
    capture_ports {
        0 system:capture_1
        1 system:capture_2

(that was .asoundrc)

load-module module-jack-sink
load-module module-jack-source 

in your /etc/pulseaudio/
but put it somewhere near the top, instead of load-module module-alsa-sink, before the ifexists module-jackdbus shit.

and rm /usr/share/alsa/alsa.conf.d/pulse.conf

Now remember that jack is running as you, so make sure that Pulseaudio is running as you as well:

sudo service pulseaudio stop
pulseaudio -v

The Payoff

Pulses playing through jack audio

At this point you can run your freshly compiled gqrx waterfall radio outputting to pulseaudio outputting to jackd and at the same time enjoy ALSA apps talking to jack directly and jack apps doing jack.